Beyond Punishment: Teachers’ Perceptions of Classroom Disruption and Behaviour Management Practices in Pakistani Secondary Schools

Authors

  • Dr. Abida Nasreen Associate Professor, Institute of Education and Research, University of the Punjab, Lahore Author
  • Dr. Anjum Naz Head of Teaching & Learning (CSA), AL. Arden University, London, UK Author
  • Zubia Hashmat Institute of Education and Research, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.63056/academia.4.6.2025.2574

Keywords:

Classroom management; school discipline; teacher perceptions; positive reinforcement; secondary education; Pakistan

Abstract

Classroom discipline is often conceptualized as the control of student misconduct, although contemporary scholarship emphasizes relational, instructional and organizational approaches to behavior support. This study revisits archival survey findings to examine how secondary-school teachers in Punjab, Pakistan, understood perceived sources of disruption and endorsed behavior-management responses. A descriptive secondary analysis was undertaken of tabulated findings from an existing cross-sectional questionnaire survey involving 302 teachers in 50 public secondary schools across Lahore and Kasur. The 52-item instrument covered perceived contributors to discipline problems (35 items) and maintenance practices (17 items). Reported item-level results indicated strong endorsement of classroom rules (93.0% agreement), concerns about overcrowded classrooms (87.7%) and aggressive teacher behaviour (90.7%), and support for reward, praise and motivation (82.1%). However, 59.6% also agreed that teachers often use corporal punishment, revealing a tension between supportive and punitive practices. The findings are descriptive measures of teacher perceptions, not direct estimates of student behavior or causal effects. Archival inconsistencies in demographic and inferential tables preclude defensible subgroup conclusions without reanalysis of the original dataset. The article argues for a school-wide, relational and instructionally grounded approach to behavior support, while identifying the importance of measurement transparency, student perspectives and stronger designs for future Pakistani research.

Downloads

Published

2025-11-29

How to Cite

Abida Nasreen, Anjum Naz, & Zubia Hashmat. (2025). Beyond Punishment: Teachers’ Perceptions of Classroom Disruption and Behaviour Management Practices in Pakistani Secondary Schools. ACADEMIA International Journal for Social Sciences, 4(6), 145-151. https://doi.org/10.63056/academia.4.6.2025.2574